A1 vs A2 Milk: This One Swap Changed Everything for Us

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. You can read the full disclosure for more information. It helps keep this site running — thank you for your support!

Let’s get real for a second—milk isn’t as simple as it used to be. Remember when your toughest milk-related decision was full-fat or skim milk?

Now, it’s a bit more complicated: organic, grass-fed, udderless almond, and now, something called A2 milk.

It turns out cow’s milk isn’t created equal. The key difference? It’s all about proteins, specifically something called beta casein. Who knew the type of beta casein lurking in your latte could affect digestion, inflammation, and even immune function?

My wife discovered this firsthand. She suffers from endometriosis, and during my deep dive into Lara Briden’s Hormone Repair Manual, I learned that A1 beta casein might mess with the immune system, potentially worsening conditions like hers.

So, she switched exclusively to A2 milk—from gentle Jersey cows, no less—and noticed a genuine improvement.

But as it turns out, it’s not just Jersey cows’ milk—goats and sheep naturally produce A2 milk too. Ever wondered why some folks digest goat cheese better than regular cow cheese? Yep, beta casein strikes again.

Is your regular milk quietly sabotaging your health? Could A2 milk genuinely reduce your bloating, inflammation, or lactose woes? And what exactly makes raw milk superior anyway?

Let’s dig into this fascinating milk mystery and discover if your coffee deserves an upgrade.

TL;DR: Quick Takeaways on A1 vs A2 Milk

• A1 vs A2 milk comes down to one key milk protein—beta casein, which affects digestion, inflammation, and overall human health.
• Many people who think they’re lactose intolerant may actually react to A1 beta casein, not the lactose itself.
• A2 milk, especially from Jersey cows, goats, or sheep, may reduce digestive discomfort, inflammation, and support immune function.
• Choosing raw milk from grass-fed A2 sources offers more enzymes, nutrients, and health benefits than most conventional cow’s milk.

What Exactly Are A1 and A2 Milk?

If you’ve ever stared at a carton of A2 milk in the supermarket wondering if it’s marketing fluff or actually worth the extra dollar, you’re not alone.

The difference between A1 and A2 milk comes down to one thing: beta casein—a type of milk protein that makes up about 30% of the total protein in cow’s milk.

Most cow’s milk on the shelf contains a mix of A1 and A2 beta casein proteins. But A1 beta casein may be causing all kinds of digestive issues in people who think they’re lactose intolerant. It’s not always the lactose—sometimes, it’s the protein.

Understanding the Difference Between A1 and A2 Beta Casein Proteins

On a molecular level, A1 and A2 beta casein differ by just one amino acid. That tiny difference might seem like nothing, but it affects how the protein is broken down during digestion.

When you drink A1 milk, it releases a peptide called BCM-7, and this is where the problems start. BCM-7 interacts with numerous opioid receptors in the body, potentially causing inflammation, slowing down digestion, and triggering symptoms like bloating, cramps, and stomach discomfort.

Not exactly what you want from your morning brew.

In contrast, A2 beta casein doesn’t break down in the same way. It seems to be much easier on the digestive system, especially for those with a self-reported intolerance to milk.

How Beta Casein Affects Your Digestion

So, when you drink milk with A1 casein protein, your body might struggle more, especially if you’re already dealing with lactose intolerance, digestive enzyme issues, or general digestive discomfort.

This is why some people who’ve ditched regular milk for alternatives like goat’s, sheep’s, or verified A2 cows’ milk find that their digestive problems improve, even though they’re still technically consuming dairy.

Next, we’ll look at what research says about these milk proteins, why A1 milk could be a risk factor for more than just gut issues, and whether you should be switching to raw milk from the right kind of cows.

The Real Issue with A1 Milk: What the Research Suggests

Now, let’s move beyond bellyaches and into the deeper stuff. Because the debate around A1 vs A2 milk isn’t just about digestive problems, there may be wider implications for human health.

While not all scientists agree (when do they ever?), several studies suggest that A1 beta casein may be linked to inflammation, changes in gastrointestinal physiology, and even a rise in certain health risks.

Why A1 Milk May Cause Digestive Issues and Discomfort

We’ve touched on BCM-7—that pesky peptide released when A1 beta casein breaks down. What makes BCM-7 a concern is its ability to latch onto the numerous opioid receptors throughout your digestive system.

This interaction can slow gut transit time, mess with digestive enzymes, and contribute to the familiar list of symptoms: bloating, cramps, loose stools, and general discomfort, especially in lactose-intolerant people.

Interestingly, some people labelled as lactose intolerant may not struggle with lactose at all—they might just be reacting to the A1 casein protein in conventional cow’s milk.

A1 Beta Casein and Its Impact on Inflammation and Immune Health

Let’s talk inflammation. Chronic, low-level inflammatory markers are increasingly seen as the quiet trigger behind everything from fatigue to heart disease.

Research suggests that A1 beta casein may elevate these markers in susceptible individuals. One study published in the Indian Journal of Endocrinology and Metabolism linked A1 beta casein to increased immune system activity, specifically, the kind we don’t want hanging around unnecessarily.

And for people with immune-related conditions, like my wife’s endometriosis, that’s a big red flag. The immune system is already working overtime, and A1 beta casein could be adding fuel to the fire.

Cognitive Behavior and the Link to A1 Protein Consumption

Here’s something that doesn’t often get talked about: the brain. Some early research has looked into how A1 milk—through BCM-7—may affect cognitive behavior, especially in children.

Again, nothing is fully conclusive, but this is where we’re seeing calls for more research into how milk proteins might influence everything from focus and energy to mood. It’s a little eerie that something as common as milk could be quietly messing with your head—literally.

So, if A1 milk has this potential downside, what about A2 milk? Is it all sunshine, rainbows, and creamy teas from here? Let’s find out.

The Health Benefits of Switching to A2 Milk

So now we know what might be going wrong with A1 milk. But what happens when you swap it for A2 milk instead?

Plenty, as it turns out.

Many people who’ve had trouble drinking milk—whether due to digestive discomfort, lactose intolerance, or general “why does milk hate me?” symptoms—find that A2 milk just sits better. Like a well-behaved guest at a barbecue. No drama, no explosions, no mad dash to the loo.

Let’s explore what makes A2 milk a more agreeable choice.

Easier Digestion for People Sensitive to Dairy

One of the biggest health benefits of A2 milk is how it behaves in your gut. Without that problematic A1 beta casein, your body doesn’t release BCM-7, which means your digestive system can often handle it more calmly.

This is especially important if you’ve ever had digestive issues after drinking regular milk but still want to enjoy dairy products without reaching for a plant-based fake milk full of additives and growth hormones.

There’s no magic here—it’s just about removing a casein protein that your body doesn’t like.

Reducing Lactose Intolerance Symptoms—A Surprising Connection

This one surprises a lot of people. You might be labelled lactose intolerant, but it’s actually the A1 protein giving you grief, not the lactose.

Several studies, including research from the Nutrition Journal, suggest that people with self-reported intolerance to cow’s milk had fewer digestive symptoms when they switched to A2 milk.

Despite no change in lactose content, there has been less bloating, cramps, and even a general reduction in digestive problems.

So no, A2 milk doesn’t magically remove lactose—it just doesn’t add insult to injury.

Lower Inflammation and Better Immune Function

Another tick in the box for A2 milk is its potential to lower inflammation in the human body.

As we touched on earlier, A1 casein can stimulate unwanted immune responses. That’s a problem if you have chronic inflammatory conditions or are trying to protect your immune system from being constantly triggered.

By switching to A2 milk, some people report feeling clearer-headed, less sluggish, and—dare I say it—“less inflamed.” It’s not a miracle cure, but if your body’s already fighting battles (especially invisible ones), removing an irritating protein can only help.

And because A2 milk still contains all the good stuff—nutrients, amino acids, and fat-soluble vitamins—you’re not giving anything up. You’re just choosing a more digestible form of high-quality dairy.

My Wife’s Experience: A2 Milk and Endometriosis

This part gets personal, but it’s the reason I started researching A1 vs. A2 milk.

My wife has endometriosis, a condition where tissue similar to the uterine lining grows where it shouldn’t. It’s painful, exhausting, and often linked to immune system dysfunction. We’d tried all the usual advice—anti-inflammatories, supplements, lifestyle changes. Some helped. Others didn’t.

Then I stumbled across a tip in Lara Briden’s Hormone Repair Manual: avoid A1 casein for three months.

Not dairy entirely—just the A1 protein, which she suggests can aggravate the immune system and prevent it from clearing the cells responsible for endometriosis.

Lara Briden’s Advice on A1 Casein and Immune Dysfunction

Briden explains that the immune system plays a big role in hormone health. If something triggers it—say, A1 beta casein—it can interfere with healing, hormone balance, and overall regulation.

That was enough for us to give it a proper go.

We cut out all conventional cow’s milk and most dairy products, apart from one exception…

How Switching to A2 Jersey Cow Milk Made a Difference

We kept A2 milk in her tea, specifically from Jersey cows, which are known to produce milk rich in A2 beta casein proteins. It wasn’t a huge sacrifice. No bowls of cereal, no creamy sauces—just a splash of proper milk in a morning brew.

But the result? Noticeable. Less to no pain. More bearable periods. And, bonus, clearer skin.

It wasn’t a miracle, but it was a real shift—one that made us question how many people are reacting to casein rather than lactose.

The Importance of Consistency: Three Months A2-Only Dairy

Here’s the key: We gave it three months, not a week, not two. The digestive system and immune function need time to calm down. It’s not just about what you remove but about giving the human body time to reset.

If you’re dealing with weird digestive symptoms, skin problems, fatigue, or anything that might be linked to chronic inflammation, swapping to A2 milk (or even better, raw milk from A2 breeds) might be worth the experiment.

Speaking of which, that brings us neatly to the next piece of the puzzle: raw milk—why it’s different, and why it plays so well with the ultimate human diet.

Why Choose Raw Milk and Grass-Fed Sources for A2 Milk?

Now we’re into the territory of what I’d call real milk—raw milk. If you’re already switching to A2 milk, choosing raw, grass-fed dairy is like moving from economy to first class.

It’s smoother, more nourishing, and just makes sense when you look at it from a human health and evolutionary lens.

Raw milk from A2 cows doesn’t just skip out on A1 beta casein—it skips out on the pasteurization process, synthetic growth hormones, and overprocessing that wrecks the enzymes, nutrients, and amino acids we’re meant to get from dairy in the first place.

Exploring Raw Milk: What Makes It Superior?

Raw milk hasn’t been heat-treated, so it keeps all its natural digestive enzymes, including lactase, which helps digest lactose. That means some folks who struggle with lactose intolerance can drink raw milk without a problem, especially when it’s also free from A1 protein.

It also contains living bacteria and bioavailable nutrients that support your digestive system, immune regulation, and overall human health.

Think of it as milk in its purest form—how nature intended before we started fiddling with it.

Grass-Fed Dairy: Maximizing Nutrients and Minimizing Health Risks

Cows fed a natural, pasture-based diet produce more nutrient-rich milk. We’re talking higher levels of omega-3s, fat-soluble vitamins, and antioxidants. And when those cows are A2 cows, it’s a double win.

You avoid potential health risks associated with A1 beta casein and get more from every drop.

Plus, let’s not forget what the Indian Journal and others have raised concerns about: processed milk proteins, inflammation, and their role in long-term human health hazards. Grass-fed, raw A2 milk keeps you closer to ancestral eating, before casein protein became complicated.

The Problem with Pasteurization and Conventional Cow’s Milk

Let’s state this clearly: The pasteurization process was designed to kill bad bacteria in poor-quality milk. But it also kills the good stuff—enzymes, vitamins, and live cultures.

Then, we try to add synthetic nutrients back in and call it “fortified.”

Most conventional cows’ milk is A1 milk, heat-treated and stripped of life. It’s often from stressed cows given growth hormones and sold as a health food.

It’s not.

So if you’re looking for high-quality dairy, raw milk from grass-fed A2 cows is the gold standard. And don’t forget: goat’s milk and sheep’s milk? Naturally A2, and often even better tolerated.

Next, let’s look at where to actually find this stuff and how to avoid buying clever marketing.

Where to Find High-Quality A2 Milk

Alright, so you’re convinced A2 might be worth a try. But unless you live next door to a smallholding with Jersey cows, tracking down genuine A2 milk can feel like a mission.

Supermarket shelves aren’t exactly helpful, especially when every carton screams “natural,” “pure,” or “from happy cows,” without saying a word about beta casein.

Let’s break it down.

Jersey Cows: Your Best Bet for A2 Milk

Jersey cows, along with Guernseys, are the MVPs of the A2 world. These heritage breeds typically produce milk with only A2 beta casein proteins, making them a solid bet if you’re looking to dodge A1 beta casein.

Small local farms, farmers’ markets, and raw dairy co-ops often keep Jerseys because of the high butterfat content and superior nutrient profile in their milk.

It’s richer, creamier, and—if it’s raw—comes packed with all the enzymes, amino acids, and natural goodness your digestive system can actually use.

Pro tip: If you’re buying directly from a farm, ask about the breed. If it’s Jersey or Guernsey, you’re likely in A2 territory.

Goat and Sheep’s Milk: Naturally High in A2 Beta Casein

Here’s where it gets easier. Goat’s milk and sheep’s milk are naturally A2. These animals have never produced the mutated A1 protein, so there’s no guesswork involved.

This makes them ideal options for people with lactose intolerance or digestive issues. They’re often more digestible, lower in allergenic proteins, and have a surprisingly close nutrient profile to human milk.

Because they fly under the radar, they usually escape the worst of industrial dairy practices—no heavy pasteurization, no growth hormones, and often grass-fed by default.

Other Cow Breeds Known to Produce Milk Rich in A2 Beta Casein

While Holsteins (the black-and-white spotted cows used in most commercial dairy) are usually A1, some other breeds lean heavily toward A2 production:

• Brown Swiss
• Shorthorn
• Normande

That said, not every cow within these breeds is 100% A2. So, unless the farm specifically tests for A2 beta casein, it’s a mixed bag.

Shopping Guide: How to Identify Genuine A2 Milk

Here’s what to look for:

✅ The label should clearly say “A2 milk” or “contains only A2 beta casein.”
✅ The source of the milk (Jersey, goat, sheep) should be identified.
✅ Raw or low-temp pasteurized options are preferable, if legally available in your area.
✅ Avoid terms like “dairy blend,” “ultra-pasteurized,” or “milk beverage”—they often mean overprocessed or diluted.

You can also check out local raw milk networks, online A2 milk directories, or ask at health food stores.

Just steer clear of flashy packaging and focus on farms and producers who care more about the cows than the slogans.

Up next—we’re diving into the cheesy side of A2: what you can eat, what to avoid, and why your gut might love it more than regular milk.

Beyond Cow’s Milk: Delicious A2 Cheeses from Goat and Sheep’s Milk

Let’s be honest—if giving up cheese sounds like a punishment, you’re not alone. Luckily, not all dairy products are off the table if you’re trying to avoid A1 beta casein.

In fact, you’ve got some delicious, gut-friendly options that are naturally rich in A2 beta casein proteins—starting with goat and sheep’s milk cheeses.

These cheeses are a brilliant way to enjoy the flavour, texture, and nutrition of dairy without the digestive problems that often come with regular milk.

Why Goat and Sheep Cheeses Might Be Easier to Digest

Here’s the beauty of it: both goat’s milk and sheep’s milk naturally contain only A2 casein. That means no A1 protein, no BCM-7, and far less chance of triggering digestive discomfort, especially in those with lactose intolerance or a sensitive digestive system.

Even people who typically avoid cow’s milk often find they can digest goat cheese or sheep cheese with no issue.

And let’s not forget—these cheeses still pack in essential amino acids, healthy fats, and plenty of flavor.

Popular Goat and Sheep A2 Cheese Varieties to Try

There’s no shortage of options here. Some of the best-loved A2-friendly cheeses include:

✅ Goat Cheese (Chevre) – Mild, creamy, and spreadable.
✅ Manchego – A rich, nutty sheep’s cheese from Spain.
✅ Feta – Traditionally made from sheep’s milk (or a blend with goat’s milk).
✅ Pecorino Romano – Hard, salty, aged sheep’s cheese—perfect for grating over meat or eggs.
✅ Halloumi – Often made from a mix of goat and sheep’s milk. Great grilled.

All of these are naturally A2, and often easier on the gut than their cow-based counterparts.

Tips for Finding Authentic A2 Cheese Products

Not every block of feta at the supermarket is made from A2 milk, so keep your eyes open:

✅ Look for labels that specify goat’s milk or sheep’s milk.
✅ Avoid feta made with cow’s milk unless the brand confirms it’s from A2 cows (like Jerseys).
✅ Visit local farm shops or order directly from artisan producers who work with traditional herds.

And don’t forget—some Jersey cow dairies now produce small-batch cheeses from 100% A2 milk. These are worth seeking out if you’re after a familiar taste without the digestive issues.

Final Thoughts: Making the Switch for Better Health

By now, it’s probably clear—not all milk is created equal. What we often call milk is usually a heavily processed product from cows producing a type of casein protein our bodies may not tolerate well.

For many people, the issue isn’t just lactose—it’s the A1 beta casein hiding in plain sight.

Switching to A2 milk, especially when it’s raw, grass-fed, and from heritage breeds like Jersey cows, or naturally A2 sources like goat’s milk and sheep’s milk, could be a simple way to ditch the digestive discomfort while keeping the health benefits of real dairy.

From improving digestion and easing lactose intolerance symptoms, to supporting your immune system and reducing unwanted inflammation, the case for choosing A2 beta casein proteins is strong, especially when your body’s already dealing with other challenges.

And as my wife’s experience with endometriosis showed us, sometimes the smallest dietary shifts—like swapping out the main protein found in your milk—can have a big impact on how you feel day to day.

So, whether you’re exploring the world of raw milk, cutting down on health risks, or just trying to find dairy that doesn’t cause bloating, it might be time to look at the difference between A1 and A2 proteins more seriously.

It’s not about fear—it’s about logic. Evolution. And a bit of common sense.

If you’re interested in other nuggets of common sense that fly in the face of mainstream advice, take a look at my thoughts on the Ultimate Human Diet, the Animal-Based diet, and even a balanced diet. Perhaps fiber, eggs, fat, and organ meats… enjoy.

And that’s it… have a nutritious day!

FAQs

Is A2 milk better than A1?

A2 milk contains only A2 beta casein, which may be easier to digest and cause fewer uncomfortable digestive symptoms, inflammation, or immune issues compared to A1 milk.

What are the disadvantages of A2 milk?

A2 milk can be more expensive and harder to find. Most store-bought milk still contains A1 beta-casein, and not all A2 products are available in raw or grass-fed forms.

Is A2 dairy inflammatory?

Studies suggest A2 dairy is less inflammatory than A1 milk due to the absence of A1 beta casein, which may trigger inflammatory markers and digestive problems in some individuals.

Is A1 or A2 raw milk better?

A2 raw milk is generally better tolerated than A1, combining easier digestion with beneficial enzymes, amino acids, and nutrients lost during the pasteurization process of conventional cow’s milk.