chopping boards with chicken, beef, pork and fish and the words "best meat box delivery"

Best Meat Box Delivery: Your Ultimate Resource [2024]

Finding high-quality, ethically sourced meat can be a challenge in today’s world of industrialized farming. Thankfully, the rise of meat delivery subscription services is making it easier than ever to enjoy premium proteins raised humanely and sustainably.

In this post, we’ll explore the top meat delivery companies that provide 100% grass-fed beef, free-range organic chicken, heritage breed pork, and wild-caught seafood conveniently shipped to your door.

Whether you’re looking for variety, value, grass-fed, organic options, or want to support regenerative agriculture, I’ve got you covered with the best meat box delivery services that meet your needs.

The Best Meat Box Delivery Companies

With so many meat subscription boxes and delivery services available, it can be tough to choose the right one. To make your decision easier, I’ve compiled the top-rated companies that specialize in everything from variety packs to 100% grass-fed programs.

Read on for my picks of the best meat box delivery services.

1. Best for Variety: U.S. Wellness Meats

U.S. Wellness Meats was founded in 2000 by forward-thinking farmers in Monticello, Missouri who pioneered new approaches to raising cattle on pasture. Their rotational grazing methods and dedication to 100% grass-fed beef transformed traditional practices.

As a family-run company, U.S. Wellness Meats remains committed to nutrition, sustainability, and humane livestock management. Their meats are pasture-raised without reliance on pesticides, herbicides, hormones, GMOs, or antibiotics.

Offerings

  • Beef
  • Bison
  • Lamb
  • Pork
  • Poultry
  • Seafood
  • Offal/Organ meat
  • Pet food
  • Other goodies such as Charcuterie Boards, chocolate, snacks, and more

How it Works

Order as much or as little as you want. Simply sift through the options and add to your basket.

U.S. Wellness Meats offers various curated bundles from pet food, carnivore collection, keto, and others.

They do not offer a subscription service currently.

Availability & Shipping

Free U.S. shipping on orders of 15lb+

Ships to all 50 states and Puerto Rico

Key Benefits

  • 100% grass-fed
  • Sustainable farming practices
  • No pesticides or herbicides
  • No antibiotics
  • No GMOs
  • No added growth hormones
  • 100% wild-caught seafood

my take

U.S. Wellness Meats

As someone who’s a big fan of organ meats and offal, I’ve got to say, U.S. Wellness Meats really hits the spot for me. They’ve got this impressive variety that just keeps me coming back for more.

But it’s not just about the organ meats. They’ve got a whole range of other meat options and treats that are perfect for anyone who loves mixing things up in their diet.

It feels good to choose healthier and more sustainable options.

Pros:
  • Impressive offal & organ meat selection
  • Wide variety of grass-fed meats
  • High-quality, sustainably raised options

Cons:

  • No subscription option

2. Best for Value: Pre

Pre prides itself with committing to 100% grass-fed/finished beef without antibiotics, hormones, or GMOs.

Their beef comes in unique vacuum-sealed packaging showcasing its tenderness. It meets dietary standards like Paleo, Keto, and Halal.

Pre believes quality beef derives from holistic cattle care. They work solely with farmers practicing true grass-finishing.

Offerings

  • Beef

How it Works

The way these guys keep their costs down is by selling in bulk. Each item can only be bought in multiples of 10.

They also provide 3 curated boxes.

Availability & Shipping

Pre delivers to 48 states.

Key Benefits

  • 100% Grass-Fed and Grass-Finished Beef
  • No added antibiotics
  • No added hormones
  • Environmentally Friendly Farming
  • Ethical Animal Welfare Standards
  • Meticulous Selection Process
  • Sustainable Transportation Practices
  • Third-Party Non-GMO Verification
  • BPA-free packaging
  • 5% discount on subscriptions

my take

Pre

Pre have focused on one thing and one thing only… beef!

In doing this it’s enabled them to supply high-quality grass-fed & grass-finished beef in simple non-toxic packaging at a fair price. And, you get an extra 5% off if you sign up for a recurring subscription.

I have to say, I love the simplicity of this company… no fluff; just the good stuff.

Pros:
  • Great Value
  • BPA-free packaging

Cons:

  • Can only in multiples of 10’s
  • Limited choices

3. Best for Organic: Rastelli’s

Rastelli’s began with a unique twist: it replaced a closed doughnut shop, marking the start of a remarkable journey in meat excellence. Founded by Ray Rastelli, Jr., this small butcher shop, initially serving local needs, blossomed into a trusted brand.

Rastelli’s, now led by Ray and his brother Tony, stands out for its commitment to quality. It’s not just a butcher shop but a symbol of sustainable and ethical practices in meat and seafood sourcing. With a rich legacy spanning over four decades, Rastelli’s embodies trust, responsibility, and a relentless pursuit of quality.

Their story isn’t just about selling meat; it’s about a family’s passion for quality, sustainability, and customer trust.

Offerings

  • Beef
  • Chicken & Turkey
  • Pork
  • Lamb
  • Bison
  • Seafood
  • Rubs & Butters
  • Oven-ready delights

How it Works

Order as much or as little as you want. Simply sift through the options and add to your basket.

Rastelli’s also offers curated boxes that they call super packs. There are 14 to choose from.

They offer one-time purchases or 1, 2, 3, 4, or 6-week subscription boxes.

Availability & Shipping

They only ship within the continental U.S. They cannot ship to Hawaii, Alaska, or Canada.

Shipping is free on orders of $200.

Key Benefits

  • Organic, 100% grass-fed, pasture-raised & Wagyu options
  • No antibiotics
  • No steroids
  • No added hormones
  • Wild-caught or sustainably raised in the wild seafood
  • Points and reward program

my take

Rastelli’s

Rastelli’s are like your local internet butchers… no matter where you are in mainland US, they’re there to serve you like a butcher should.

They have a fantastic range of organic beef, chicken, and pork. So, if buying organic is important to you, then Rastelli’s are your guys for sure.

Pros:
  • Great organic selection
  • Wagyu options

Cons:

  • High minimum for free shipping

Interested in finding out more about certified organic meat?

In my post answering the question about what organic meat is, I explain the exact requirements to become certified as well as some facts that might surprise you.

4. Best for Grass-fed: White Oak Pastures

Established in 1995, White Oak Pastures championed a shift from conventional farming to regenerative methods. Their diverse ecosystem and zero-waste philosophy revitalized their rural Georgia community.

They repurpose cattle byproducts and process meat on-site, in contrast to factory farming. As a Global Savory Hub, they focus on grassland restoration and environmental stewardship.

Offerings

  • Beef
  • Lamb
  • Pork
  • Poultry
  • Rabbit
  • Offal/Organ Meat
  • Pet food
  • Other goodies such as preserves, leather goods, Tallow candles, and skincare

How it Works

Order as much or as little as you want. Simply sift through the options and add to your basket.

White Oak Pastures offers curated bundles, including fractional cow shares. Bundles can be purchased one-time or by subscription.

All of these can be ordered as a one-off or as a subscription with a 10% saving.

Availability & Shipping

White Oak Pastures provides delivery to 48 states, with shipping costs varying based on your location.

To understand the specific rates for your area, check out the shipping map for additional details.

Ground Shipping

  • Free on orders over $249
  • $15 on orders between $150 and $249
  • $20 on orders under $149

Express Shipping

  • Calculated per pound per mile by their shipping providers UPS and FedEX.

Key Benefits

  • Great selection of choices
  • All meat & products are from their farm in Bluffton, Georgia.
  • Regenerative farming – carbon-negative farming
  • Zero-waste farm
  • Certified grass-fed (and grass-finished)
  • Certified Humanely raised animals
  • Ecological Outcome Verified in the Land2Market Program
  • No Antibiotics
  • No steroids
  • No added growth hormones
  • On-farm red meat and poultry processing
  • Temple Grandin designed abattoir

my take

White Oak Pastures

White Oak Pastures is genuinely impressive. I’m struck by their holistic approach to sustainable farming. The way they utilize every part of the animal in their zero-waste philosophy just resonates with me. It’s not just about being efficient; it’s about respect and responsibility towards the environment.

Their dedication to regenerative grazing and holistic management practices makes every product they offer not just high-quality, but also environmentally conscious. I find that inspiring.

Pros:
  • Utilizes every part of the animal
  • Regenerative and sustainable farming practices

Cons:

  • Maybe expensive for some
  • Minimum of $249 for free delivery

Interested in finding out more about grass-fed meat?

Head over to my post where I dig deep into what it is, the benefits, the downsides and tips on how to best cook grass-fed beef, head-on over to my Grass-fed post.

5. Best for Regenerative Farming: Thousand Hills Lifetime Grazed

Did you know that Thousand Hills Lifetime Grazed has been a trailblazer in regenerative agriculture since 2003? Led by Matt Maier, they’re all about reviving soil health and boosting biodiversity with their smart grazing methods.

Think of it as giving the land a makeover into lush, diverse grasslands. They’re part of the North American Savory Institute Hubs and work magic with over 50 U.S. farms, affecting a whopping 600,000 acres!

Here’s the cool part: their 100% Grass Fed Beef is totally free from grain by-products, hormones, antibiotics, and GMOs.

Offerings

  • Beef
  • Offal/Organ meat
  • Bone broth
  • Pork
  • Eggs
  • Honey & Beeswax products

How it Works

Order as much or as little as you want. Simply sift through the options and add to your basket.

Thousand Hills offers 7 curated beef boxes from simple ground beef only to a mixture of different beef items.

Availability & Shipping

Free delivery on orders over $249.

Key Benefits

my take

Thousand Hills Lifetime Grazed

Thousand Hills Lifetime Grazed offers exceptionally nutrient-dense, grass-fed beef. Their regenerative farm practices are admirable; producing healthier, naturally flavorful meat, earning customer praise.

For nutrient-rich beef from animals that have lived a good life, they are a top choice.

Pros:
  • 100% Grass-fed beef
  • Beef organ meat options

Cons:

  • No custom box options
  • Minimum order $249 for free delivery

6. Best for Meat Subscription Boxes: ButcherBox

ButcherBox specializes in delivering ethically sourced, high-quality meats, including grass-fed beef, free-range organic chicken, humanely raised pork, and wild-caught seafood.

They prioritize animal welfare, with Australian-sourced, freely roaming cattle, and sustainably farmed poultry and pork, ensuring free-range, GAP 3 certified conditions, and heritage breed pork on vegetarian diets.

ButcherBox offers these diverse meat selections with the convenience of free shipping, reflecting a strong commitment to ethical and sustainable practices.

Offerings

  • Beef
  • Chicken
  • Pork
  • Seafood

How it Works

ButcherBox is purely a meat box delivery service.

They offer both curated and custom box options:

  • Custom box – classic ($169) & big box ($306)
  • Mixed box – classic ($146) & big box ($269)
  • Beef & Chicken box – classic ($146) & big box ($269)
  • Beef & Pork box – classic ($146) & big box ($269)

Availability & Shipping

Butcher Box delivers to 48 states and shipping is free on all orders.

Key Benefits

  • Free shipping
  • 100% grass-fed beef
  • Free-range organic chicken
  • Pork raised crate-free
  • Wild-caught fish
  • Humanely raised
  • No antibiotics
  • Eco-friendly packaging

my take

ButcherBox

Butcher Box are the perfect choice for automated meat delivery service (a close 2nd would be Crowd Cow – Crowd Cow are worth checking out). They deliver superior meat and seafood right to your home, offering an easy and dependable solution for savoring high-quality meat.

Although the choices for customization are limited, the convenience and ease of use make them a worthwhile choice.

Pros:
  • Convenient and easy to automate
  • High-quality meat & seafood
  • Free shipping

Cons:

  • Only subscription-based service
  • Limited customization options

7. Best for Steak: Certified Piedmontese

Certified Piedmontese stands out in the world of beef with its unique Italian-heritage Piedmontese cattle. Embracing a farm-to-fork approach, they ensure traceability, sustainability, and humane animal handling.

Raised on Midwest family ranches, their beef is all-natural, free from antibiotics, steroids, or hormones. This commitment to natural processes and quality results in beef that is not only flavorful but also healthier, with lower calories and fat compared to traditional beef.

Their vision is to be the trusted source for sustainable Piedmontese beef, maintaining authenticity and honesty in every interaction. They take pride in their Grass Finished Program, where cattle are grass-fed, producing leaner meat with more omega-3 fatty acids and CLA, making it the healthier choice.

Offerings

  • It’s mostly about the beef!
  • Seafood
  • Pork
  • Chicken
  • Wagyu
  • Lamb
  • Duck
  • Bison
  • Cured meat

How it Works

Order as much or as little as you want. Simply sift through the options and create your own box.

They do curated gift boxes to gift to others for birthdays, anniversaries, or any other reason – although I can’t see any reason why you couldn’t gift yourself… because why not?

Then you’ve got the Certified Piedmontese Beef Club which is a subscription box service. They offer 2 options; The Gourmet Butcher and The Fancy Rancher. Both of these can be on a monthly or quarterly basis.

Availability & Shipping

Free shipping on orders over $150

Key Benefits

  • U.S. raised Piedmontese cattle
  • Wide selection of steaks
  • Quality Guarantee
  • Verified Non-GMO
  • 100% grass-finished options
  • No antibiotics
  • No steroids
  • No added hormones
  • Sustainably-sourced seafood

my take

Certified Piedmontese

With 85% of grass-fed beef consumed in the U.S. being imported, Certified Piedmontese are proud to produce all their meat in the U.S. in the great Midwest – And rightly so.

Their steak selection is impressive so if you’re a fan of a good U.S. raised ribeye, filet mignon, New York Strip, T-Bone, Sirloin filet, or any other cut you can think of, then Certified Piedmontese is for you.

Pros:
  • Great steak selection
  • Expansive selection of beef and other meats

Cons:

  • Perhaps too many choices for some

8. Best for Grass-fed Wagyu: First Light Farms

First Light Farms, a pioneering New Zealand company, is revolutionizing the meat industry with its innovative approach. Starting with pasture-raised venison, they made history by introducing the world’s first 100% grass-fed wagyu beef.

Their commitment to producing tender, healthy, and delicious meat has garnered international acclaim, including gold medals at prestigious competitions like the World Steak Challenge and the Steak of Origin.

Founded by Jason Ross and his friends in 2003, First Light Farms faced challenges in establishing Japanese wagyu cattle in New Zealand, overcoming skepticism and traditional norms. Their persistence and dedication to quality have paid off, with their grass-fed wagyu being a consumer favorite.

Offerings

  • Wagyu Beef
  • Venison
  • Elk
  • Supplements
  • Wagyu hides

How it Works

You can order as little or as much as you want here.

First Light Farms offers 6 gift boxes for you to gift to whoever you want, including yourself.

They even have an exclusive ‘Steak Club‘ which is their monthly meat delivery subscription offering either the Classic or Steakhouse Membership. There’s a waiting list to join but if you’re fortunate enough to get in there, you’ll get the best Wagyu they have to offer with marble scores of 5+ along with other perks.

Availability & Shipping

TBC

Key Benefits

  • 100% grass-fed
  • Non GMO project certified
  • No antibiotics
  • No added hormones
  • Animal welfare approved
  • Certified humane

my take

First Light Farms

Being a big fan of 100% grass-fed meat – mostly because that’s what ruminants are supposed to be – Wagyu was off the plate for me due to its usual grain finishing. Then First Light Farms came along and now all is good in the world.

I love their determination to do the seemingly un-doable. Just to top it off, they provide some of my other favorite things, organ meat, and liver supplements… Amazing!

If you love Wagyu, I urge you to give these guys a go, and why not throw in some, elk, venison supplements, and a cowhide for good measure… what the hell.

Pros:
  • Awesome selection of grass-fed Wagyu
  • Elk and Venison offerings
  • Organ supplements

Cons:

  • What’s not to like?

Want to know more about organ meat supplements and liver supplements, check out my posts for the best on the market.

9. Best for Exotic Meats: Fossil Farms

Fossil Farms, founded by brothers Lance and Todd Appelbaum in 1997, is a testament to turning a vision into reality. Inspired by the unique taste and sustainable nature of game meats, they started with raising ostrich and bison, driven by Todd’s farming dream and Lance’s entrepreneurial spirit.

Today, Fossil Farms stands as a leader in offering high-quality farm-raised game, game birds, exotic meats, and all-natural meats.

Their mission is not to be the biggest but to be the BEST in terms of product quality and service. Fossil Farms challenges the conventional meat industry, advocating for sustainable and healthy alternatives to factory-farmed meats.

Offerings

Probably easier to say what they don’t offer. Here’s a screen shot of their offerings:

Lists of Fossil Farms meat choices

How it Works

Order as much or as little as you want. Wanna give some ostrich a go, perhaps snap up some alligator or even go all out with some Japanese Wagyu… then crack on.

Availability & Shipping

They ship to the United States, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico.

Free shipping on orders of $175 or more.

Key Benefits

  • 10% discount for Military, first responders, and medical
  • No growth hormones
  • No antibiotics
  • No steroids
  • Non-GMO grains
  • 100% grass-fed
  • Pasture-raised
  • Cage-free
  • Whole animal philosophy
  • 100% recyclable packaging

my take

Fossil Farms

If you’re bored of the usual meat offerings and want to try something different, then Fossil Farms is for you.

What I love about them is that their exotic variety does not compromise on quality and animal welfare. They are clearly passionate about doing things right.

If you fancy a kangaroo medallion or camel burger then check these guys out.

Pros:
  • Loads of exotic choices
  • Delivers to Hawaii and Puerto Rico

Cons:

  • Nada

Buyer’s Guide to Choosing the Best Meat Box Delivery Company

When selecting a meat delivery service, consider your priorities in terms of budget, customization, sustainability, and more. High-quality, humanely raised meat tends to cost more than current meat commodity system options.

Analyze subscription plans to find the right balance of variety, volume, and delivery frequency for your needs. Seek out companies aligned with your values around organic, grass-fed, and regenerative practices. Read reviews and try sampler boxes first.

With the rise of the specialty meat delivery service, you can now access premium meat, shipped fresh or frozen straight to your front door.

Conclusion

Here I’ve provided 9 options dependant on what you’re seeking when it comes to meat delivery subscription boxes. Whether you’re looking for a good piece of steak from Certified Piedmontese or an alligator burger from Fossil Farms.

Perhaps you want to support regenerative farming with Thousand Hills Lifetime Grazed, or seeking numerous grass-fed options with White Oak Pastures, or just want plenty of variety of high quality meat from U.S. Wellness Meats.

Maybe choosing certified organic with Rastelli’s, grass-fed Wagyu with First Light Farms or good quality for a reasonable cost with Pre.

Whatever your preferences, I hope you’ve found the right meat delivery service for you… enjoy!

That’s it… have a nutritious day!

FAQs

Is ButcherBox meat worth it?

Yes, ButcherBox provides high-quality grass-fed and sustainably raised meat worth the price for many consumers. While it costs more than generic grocery store meat, you get the assurance of transparent sourcing and production practices. For those who value eating clean, humanely raised meat, the premium is justified.

Does ButcherBox meat come from China?

No, ButcherBox does not source any meat from China. Their beef is grass-fed and sourced from Australia and Uruguay. Pork and chicken come from heritage breed suppliers in the U.S. and Canada following sustainable practices. ButcherBox aims to provide full traceability back to family farms.

What does ButcherBox cost a month?

ButcherBox subscription pricing ranges from $129-$270 monthly depending on box size and contents. For the basic 8-10 lbs Classic Box, expect to pay $129/month plus shipping. The Big Box at 16-22 lbs costs $238/month. Custom boxes and add-ons can increase the monthly total.

Is it cheaper to buy meat online?

Buying meat online from direct-to-consumer suppliers can represent significant savings over local retail for the same quality cuts. However, premium meat from regenerative and grass-fed sources may cost more than typical grocery store selections. Shop around to find an online supplier with competitive bulk pricing.

Are meat packs worth it?

Meat packs and subscriptions can provide good value for money on high-quality cuts, especially if buying grass-fed, organic, or sustainably raised meat. Make sure to compare pricing and read reviews. Consider trying a sampler box first. The convenience of delivery can make packs worthwhile for some households.

What is the best quality meat you can buy?

The highest quality meat comes from animals raised on pasture and grass without antibiotics, hormones, or GMOs. Look for certifications like 100% grass-fed, grass-finished, organic, and Animal Welfare Approved. Regenerative farms focused on soil health and sustainability offer premium quality. High-end Wagyu beef is also celebrated for rich marbling although feed practices vary.

Similar Posts